First Thrown Stone by Stanton Yeakley

The dinner was a mea culpa. A peace pipe. An outstretched hand to say, despite what you might think of us, we aren’t Puritans.

Of course, what Lily and her husband, Dane, thought of us was far from true anyway. We could feel hate oozing from them the minute they walked through the door. While we cooed over Lily’s new hair, fawned at Dane’s (somewhat dramatic) weight loss, took their coats like housemaids, their demeanor stayed cold, distant. They didn’t try to hide it. Judy Williams whispered that Lily looked like she wanted to vomit when she saw the authentic headdress hanging from the foyer wall.

“Appreciation, not appropriation,” Judy coughed. “That thing cost more than her car. All these years, Lily still doesn’t understand.”

We agreed, but kept quiet. Judgment wasn’t in the spirit of apology. We showed our guests to the dining room where Abigail Collins had laid out her best china and flatware. Cloth swans floated on milky plates and bottles of champagne dotted the centerpieces, guarding floral arrangements like sentries.

God. We really were groveling.

And who could blame us? In an effort to make Edmond Public Schools safer, we had crossed a line. One we hadn’t known was there, but one that we willingly acknowledged had been crossed: We called Lily Gooday a witch.

To be fair, even in college she had been different. We used to pepper Dane with stories about her running out of dorm rooms naked in the moonlight, clay skin bare to the world—about her attending class in nothing but howling wolf tee shirts and dangling feather earrings. The origin and veracity of these rumors was unclear, but we shared them with abandon. We had grown up with Dane. Been members of the same church, same school, same country club. We felt obligated to protect him. Lily, meanwhile, was a newcomer—attending our tiny Christian college on a softball scholarship. Lily didn’t go to church; she went to powwows. To be honest, none of us were convinced she had ever seen a Bible. We wondered whether one would burn her if she touched it. All in good fun.

But, when we graduated, she was still with Dane, and like the rest of us, they stuck around the city. Lily coached softball and taught biology at Edmond North. We saw them at game nights and holiday parties and sometimes Dane even managed to drag her to worship when she wasn’t too tired from being out all Saturday. Honestly, she was becoming so respectable, it’s a shame what happened.

Everything began last summer when our kids started high school. Reading lists were mailed out in early June and, being dutiful parents, we bought the books immediately. This turned out to be our first mistake. Because the money would have been better spent on issues of Playboy.

They were pornography, plain and simple. Every book was filled with penises, breasts, premarital sex. Children “discovering” their homosexuality. Abortion and sodomy. Understandably, we were upset. So, we did what any loving parents would do. We picketed school boards, occupied PTA meetings, and petitioned to have the English teacher fired.

Along the way, we had a few heated skirmishes, some involving close friends.

“Are you really trying to keep books out of schools, Judy? Have some faith in your kids.”

Lily was at the microphone during a board meeting in September. She was wearing a beautiful denim dress but her arms were bare. Tattoos shown down to her wrists.

“I don’t co-parent with the government,” Judy shouted.

The crowd roared its approval.

More school board meetings followed, but we continued to see Dane every few weeks, and Lily remained in the group chat. The relationship felt salvageable.

Then, in October, Abigail’s daughter brought home the vulture feathers. Her father found them strewn across her bedroom like discarded talismans. When pressed, she admitted that Mrs. Gooday gave them to her. That same week, Anna Walter was caught smuggling owl pellets in the front pocket of her backpack. When her mother discovered them—hands running over fresh crumbles of rat bone and cat hair—Jenny also said the freakish remnants came from Lily. These coincidences might have been explainable, even forgivable, but the Damien incident tipped us over the edge.

Now, we should have known better than to rest our case on young Damien, but the confluence of events was too much. A week after the buzzard feathers, days after the owl feces, Damien Williams was caught playing with the yellow skull of a Mississippi kite in his sister’s room. He gazed at the bird’s hooked beak under a plastic magnifying glass, transfixed. When asked, he said his sister got it from Mrs. Gooday. He said Mrs. Gooday was a witch.

Only then, fumbling through these strange events, did we remember what Lily said to us at the last school board meeting.

You’re going to regret this someday.

“Damien’s right,” Abigail Collins whispered, careful not to speak too loud. “I think Lily’s a witch. Wiccan or something. A medicine woman.”

So, being concerned parents, we told the school board. We told them about the feathers and the bones and the skulls. We told them our children had been acting strangely—talking back, breaking curfew, carrying around bird bones—and that Lily Gooday was to blame.

“You’re ruining my life,” Lily hissed at the hearing that followed. “All because I asked for some restraint? Because I didn’t want you banning books?”

And, because she was teaching a biology course on avian anatomy apparently, but that didn’t come out at the hearings. When someone raised the matter of book advocacy with the State Superintendent, he and the Department of Education agreed Mrs. Gooday had to go. Lily never presented her case. The whole proceeding lasted a few minutes. She was fired within the week. Meanwhile, the Birds 101: Basic Anatomy and Interactive Diagramming worksheets weren’t discovered until a month later, and only then did it dawn on us that eight-year-old Damien didn’t know bitch is something his sister might call her biology teacher when she assigns too much homework.

Ergo, the dinner.

We sat down as catering staff filled our glasses. Dane eased into his chair, wearing the agonized look of someone perched on barbed wire. Lily was silent. Oddly calm. While we waited to be served, those of us with enough humility to engage our guests chatted, tossed easy questions at them, forced compliments that required such mental gymnastics we deserved medals. Mercifully, just as we were running out of ways to be courteous, a clink sounded from the head of the table.

“A toast,” Abigail called, lifting her champagne. “To our old friends. Dane, Lily. I know we’ve said this already, but we can’t say it enough. We are truly sorry.”

Dane nodded and faintly lifted his glass. Lily stared at Abigail and smiled. It was the happiest she had seemed all evening. “Thank you so much for saying that. I’d like to return the favor if you don’t mind.”

Abigail shrugged. “Of course.”

Lily adjusted her dress and rose from her seat.

“To all of you,” she began, surveying the table. “Some of my oldest, closest friends. A toast to your health. To all your dreams, schemes, and wishes.” We clinked glasses and drank, but Lily remained standing. She glanced down at a notecard she was holding. “May you live to see the world you make, and may you reap the fruits of your labor.” More clinks. “May you spread your arms wide across that world.” Maybe she was in a forgiving mood. “And may it devour you.”

No clinks there.

“May it pick at you like vultures, like a dog picks at sores.”

We put down our glasses. Dane looked at his wife pleadingly.

“May your children turn against you for what you’ve done—for what you continue to do. May they leave you outside when the sun flays the land and the sea floods your levees. And when you’re old, when you’re forced to reckon with this mindless, scorched world, may your children banish you like those same sore-picking dogs. May they cast you out and may fucking boils consume you. May you finally get what you deserve.”

Then she put away her notecard and sat down. Lily clinked glasses with a reluctant Dane and they each took a drink.  Lily had not stopped smiling. As she dug into her food, neither she nor Dane noticed the eyes catching across the room. We were horrified. The things she wished on us—at a table where we’d gathered to apologize. At a meal we paid for to make her feel better. We were distraught.

But we were also relieved. As we sat with Lily’s words, a weight lifted from every shoulder hunched over plates of bloody steak and lamb. Praise Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. We were absolved. We were right.

Lily Gooday was a witch.


Stanton Yeakley lives and writes in the Bible Belt, where he works as an attorney and cares for a 150-year-old house. He has been previously published in BarBar magazine, BULL, Evening Street Review, Haunted Waters Press, New Plains Review, and Thimble Literary Magazine, among others. Website: https://www.stantonyeakley.com.

vagabondcityfiction's avatar
vagabondcityfiction